Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Fundamentals
Realistic Strategies, Realistic Returns

COI Fundamentals Issue: October 16, 2023

The market rally in 2023 and recent pullback have left the All-Weather portfolio up a respectable 4.5%, with our poor man’s covered call in the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI) continuing to do the heavy lifting, up 21.4%. The S&P 500 is flat over the same time frame.

Our SPDR Gold Shares ETF (GLD) position has been resurgent of late. After being down roughly 20%, our poor man’s covered call position in GLD now sits 7% higher.

Click here to register for the subscriber-exclusive event tomorrow, Tuesday, October 17 at noon Eastern Time (ET).

Current Positions

Click here to access the “Portfolios” section to view each portfolio’s respective positions.

Portfolio Discussion

All-Weather Portfolio

The market rally in 2023 and recent pullback have left the All-Weather portfolio up a respectable 4.5%, with our poor man’s covered call in the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI) continuing to do the heavy lifting, up 21.4%. The S&P 500 is flat over the same time frame.

Our SPDR Gold Shares ETF (GLD) position has been resurgent of late. After being down roughly 20%, our poor man’s covered call position in GLD now sits 7% higher.

The performance of the overall portfolio is certainly nothing to write home about, at least at the moment, but the portfolio has been far less volatile and requires far less capital (65% to 85% less) compared to a stock-based portfolio using the same underlying ETFs.

Nothing has changed from last expiration cycle, both bond funds (TLT and IEF) and the commodity fund (DBC) continue to lag behind, but that is the yin-yang protective nature of the All-Weather portfolio just doing its job. That being said, all of our positions continue to outperform their respective ETF benchmarks, once again showing the power of using a poor man’s covered call approach.

We have several short call positions that need to be rolled this week including GLD, VTI, DBC and IEF.

Yale Endowment Portfolio

Our Yale Endowment portfolio is up 9.2%.

The S&P 500 (SPY) up 17.7%, emerging markets (EEM) up 2%, and the European Union (EFA) up 11.4% have led the way for the Yale Endowment Fund while bonds (TIP) and real estate (VNQ) have lagged.

As we head towards the September 15 expiration cycle, we need to roll our VNQ September 15, 2023, 85 calls and our SPY September 15, 2023, 466 calls this week

Dogs (and Small Dogs) of the Dow

Our Dogs approach continues to be a tale of two portfolios since the beginning of 2023. Our Small Dogs portfolio continues to rise, currently sitting up 6.9%, while our Dogs of the Dow portfolio is down 4.2% since the onset of 2023. If the market rallies into the end of the year we should see significant gains going forward. Both portfolios saw significant gains over the past several expiration cycles, but the September 15 expiration cycle and October 20 expiration cycles proved to be a bit more challenging as we saw overall returns pull back.

Three out of five Small Dogs are in positive territory with Intel (INTC) leading the way, up 74.1% on the year while the stock is only up 30.1%. Cisco Systems (CSCO) is not too far behind with a return of 32.5% while the stock has only gained 12.3%. Dow (DOW) is slightly above break-even. Verizon (VZ) has been the big loser so far this year, down 40.1%.

As for the remaining higher-priced stocks that make up the rest of the Dogs of the Dow (including the Small Dogs), the hands-down winner continues to be JPMorgan (JPM). Our position is up 27.6%, while the stock is only up 7.7%. Unfortunately, JPM is only one of two winners among the remaining holdings in the portfolio (5). AMGN is the other and has made a roaring come back. If the largest holding in the portfolio manages to close out the year with a nice rally the overall portfolio should close well into positive territory.

We have several short call positions that need to be rolled this week including INTC, WBA, MMM, CVX and JPM.

Warren Buffett’s Patient Investor Portfolio

At the moment, we have three positions (AAPL, GOOGL, TXN) and intend to add several more over the coming week or so, if the market cooperates … again, a statement we’ve been making for quite some time now.

Back in late June we added Alphabet (GOOGL). Since adding the position, we are up 51.0%, while the overall stock is up only 14.1%.

I wish we could say similar things about our position in Texas Instruments (TXN). Our position started off great, but a sour earnings report several cycles ago pushed the position lower and as a result, TXN hasn’t recovered.

Our longest standing position, AAPL, is up 6% after being down close to 25% just a few months ago. But only a month or two ago our position was up over 20%. A rally will obviously help to push our position back to recent highs, and until then we will continue to lower our cost basis by selling more and more call premium.

As I have written in our last few issues, I will be building out the portfolio to a minimum of five positions over the coming expiration cycles, and remember, because this is an active portfolio, we will be rebalancing every month around expiration. Rebalance occurs around each expiration, with the most recent around the October 20 expiration cycle.

James O’Shaughnessy’s Growth/Value Portfolio

Absolutely nothing has changed since last expiration – except the returns. Like the Patient Investor portfolio, my Growth/Value portfolio continues to take a cautious approach. My hope is to add at least two to three positions over the next few expiration cycles. Of course, we’ve been planning this approach for several months, but our indicators and low options premium have kept us on the sidelines, and thankfully so.

However, we did have the good fortune to add a position in TotalEnergies (TTE) back in late June; so far, so good as our position is up 72.6%, while the underlying stock is up only 15.2%.

The market is beginning to accommodate our cautiously optimistic stance. I’ve allowed the passive portfolios (All-Weather and Yale Endowment) to do a lot of the hard work. But, with the market selling off throughout much of the last month (which has led to an increase in options premium) coupled with a seasonally bullish period ahead, well, expect to see a few positions added to the mix to hopefully contribute to the overall cause.

Next Live Analyst Briefing with Q&A

Our next Live Analyst Briefing with Q&A is scheduled for tomorrow, October 17, 2023, at 12 p.m. ET, where we will be discussing the options market, giving a detailed look at open positions, strategies used, and will have a follow-up with live questions and answers. Register here.


The next Cabot Options Institute – Fundamentals issue will be published on

November 13, 2023.

Andy Crowder is a professional options trader, researcher and Senior Analyst at Cabot. Formerly with Oppenheimer & Co. in New York, Andy has leveraged his investment experience to develop his statistically based options trading strategy which applies probability theory to option valuations in order to execute risk-controlled trades. This proprietary strategy has been refined through two decades of research and real-world experience and has been featured in the Wall Street Journal, Seeking Alpha, and numerous other financial publications. Andy has helped thousands of option traders learn and implement his meticulous rules-driven options trading strategies through highly attended conferences, one-on-one coaching, webinars, and his work as a financial columnist. He currently resides in Bolton Valley, Vermont and when he’s not trading, teaching and writing about options, he enjoys spending time with his wife and two daughters, backcountry skiing, biking, running and enjoying all things outdoors.